Forty things people believe about hiring, taken apart one weekday at a time.Written by Stori's founder, Fraser Hill.
Hiring Myths 1 of 40
We keep believing that refining the same interviews, frameworks and tools will finally fix hiring. It won't.
Hiring Myths 2 of 40
AI shouldn't replace human judgement in hiring. It should replace everything that *stops* humans judging well.
Hiring Myths 3 of 40
We keep believing that one day — better AI, better tests — we'll finally *solve* hiring. We won't.
Hiring Myths 4 of 40
Companies love to say they hire the best people. They usually hire people who are good enough — and those aren't the same thing.
Hiring Myths 5 of 40
Competency interviews don't measure competence. They measure who can produce a fitting story on cue.
Hiring Myths 6 of 40
If one interviewer isn't producing good evidence, adding four more won't magically fix it.
Hiring Myths 7 of 40
Mention a bad manager or a conflict in an interview and you become the red flag — as if the trouble must have been you.
Hiring Myths 8 of 40
'What's your favourite interview question?' The idea that one brilliant question reveals brilliant people is one of hiring's biggest myths.
Hiring Myths 9 of 40
Nobody remembers their career as a list of competencies. Hiring has spent decades pretending we do.
Hiring Myths 10 of 40
'AI is biased.' Biased according to whom? It learned everything it knows from us.
Hiring Myths 11 of 40
The tough interview is a badge of honour. I've never understood it.
Hiring Myths 12 of 40
'Culture fit.' I've never been convinced anyone can actually define it.
Hiring Myths 13 of 40
Leadership: 84. Communication: 91. Those numbers feel reassuring. What do they actually mean?
Hiring Myths 14 of 40
Great companies aren't necessarily great at hiring. They're great at *attracting* — and that's not the same thing.
Hiring Myths 15 of 40
'Tell me about a time you demonstrated leadership' assumes you can search your memory like Google. You can't.
Hiring Myths 16 of 40
Some of the best people I've worked with had ordinary resumes — until you heard the story behind them.
Hiring Myths 17 of 40
Isn't it interesting that we only started demanding explanations for hiring decisions once a machine was involved?
Hiring Myths 18 of 40
Great companies are great at interviewing. Not so fast.
Hiring Myths 19 of 40
Most companies think better hiring comes from more information. It comes from *better* information.
Hiring Myths 20 of 40
Everyone says they hire for potential. Nobody can honestly define it.
Hiring Myths 21 of 40
A polished, confident answer feels like enough. It tells you almost nothing.
Hiring Myths 22 of 40
We interview as if there's one ideal candidate for the role — a generic avatar who'd be great on any team.
Hiring Myths 23 of 40
Twenty years chasing 'unconscious bias' rests on shakier ground than most people realise.
Hiring Myths 24 of 40
There is no such thing as the best candidate. It took me years to understand why.
Hiring Myths 25 of 40
The skills-based hiring debate is happening one layer too high.
Hiring Myths 26 of 40
A standout achievement feels like proof. On its own it tells you almost nothing.
Hiring Myths 27 of 40
The industry keeps inventing more traits to measure. We've probably identified too many already.
Hiring Myths 28 of 40
In a world where everything before the interview can be AI-generated, the interview matters more than ever — as a ledger, not a competency quiz.
Hiring Myths 29 of 40
People tell me stories aren't evidence. I think they're some of the richest evidence we have.
Hiring Myths 30 of 40
Candidates have been trained to hide the most interesting parts of their careers. It's one of interviewing's biggest failures.
Hiring Myths 31 of 40
Referrals don't work because they find the best candidate. They work because they reduce uncertainty.
Hiring Myths 32 of 40
One company asks about ping-pong balls in a bus, another asks your weaknesses — and both hire capable people. So how much is the interview really doing?
Hiring Myths 33 of 40
People talk about a talent shortage. I think we have an *evidence* shortage.
Hiring Myths 34 of 40
Science transformed medicine and engineering. I don't think it transformed hiring.
Hiring Myths 35 of 40
We give references an authority they were never designed to have.
Hiring Myths 36 of 40
Everyone says AI is coming for our jobs. I think it's coming for our weak hiring signals.
Hiring Myths 37 of 40
'A players, B players, C players.' An A player compared to whom?
Hiring Myths 38 of 40
Hiring spends all its time debating the evidence — and almost none debating what that evidence is evidence *of*.
Hiring Myths 39 of 40
The STAR method assumes your career compresses neatly into four boxes. Real careers don't.
Hiring Myths 40 of 40
'AI killed the resume.' It didn't — it exposed what the resume was always missing.